Thursday, October 27, 2022

Gig Review: The Sisters of Mercy @ Hunter Lounge, Wellington, 26 October 2022

They say you should never meet your heroes. The idea being that they seldom live up to expectation and it often only ever results in disappointment. Sometimes, a variation on that old adage can be applied to seeing your favourite bands perform live. More so, if you’re seeing the band for the first time, some 35 years after their feted heyday.

Such was the case when The Sisters of Mercy played at the Hunter Lounge in Wellington on Wednesday night. Maybe I just expected too much. Perhaps it was because I was a little too sober. I’d read and heard mostly positive reviews of the band’s Auckland set the night prior, and felt confident that Sisters v.22 would match my own not unreasonable expectations.

All I wanted was the “hits”, some atmosphere, the requisite quota of melodramatic darkness, and a decent light show. Not too much to ask.

What we got was somewhat less than all of the above. Sure, we got the biggest hits (hits, in context of the 1980s indie charts), but we also got a lot of new-ish, unreleased material - around 50 percent of the set list - which ultimately failed to stir the loins, and virtually all of the hits felt a lot less than the sum of their original parts.

When the set opened with ‘Don’t Drive on Ice’, a relative newbie which wouldn’t have been out of place on the band’s faux-metal Vision Thing album, it felt a little bit like hearing a very good karaoke replica. The sound was thin, a little tinny even, and I felt certain the volume inside the packed venue was somehow muted, if not a little muddy. Surely they’ll amp things up and sort out the mix?

But no, nothing changed as we weaved our way through a 20-something strong set list. Newer tunes were dispersed at regular intervals, easily the best of which was ‘But Genevieve’, alongside a run of better known work which included a lightweight ‘Alice’, ‘Marian’, ‘More’, ‘Detonation Boulevard’ and The Sisterhood epic, ‘Giving Ground’, which briefly had me upping my inner goth to feet shuffling and head-nod mode. Nothing really pulsated my chest or buckled my knees.

I was pleased Vision Thing’s slower-paced sleeper gem ‘I Was Wrong’ was included, but by this time I was despairing a little too much for main man Andrew Eldritch, his once majestically deep baritone now a mere shadow, replaced in 2022 with a sort of unhappy-go-lucky growl.

When the time for an obligatory encore arrived, the band did appear to up the ante a bit, perhaps in anticipation that their night’s work was almost done, and versions of ‘Lucretia, My Reflection’, ‘Temple of Love’, and ‘This Corrosion’ were as good as could be expected, given the rest of the night.

I get that sometimes a band can become tour-worn and jaded. I get that a band can fall prone to merely phoning-in a performance on occasion. And I get that a band wants to introduce new work to an audience ostensibly there to celebrate the stuff they already know.

But the gig just lacked “soul”. There was no real sense of authenticity. Both guitarists could well have been cutouts from a Sisters tribute act, and Eldritch himself was fairly underwhelming as a posturing frontman just going through the motions. Almost like he was trying to resist the urge to take the piss out of himself and failing badly. And yes, I appreciate that you can’t ever take this genre too seriously … and sometimes you should never meet your heroes.

PS. The support act was Brisbane duo Elko Fields, a curious mix of the White Stripes and The Kills’ aesthetic, and they played about half a dozen raucous songs to an enthusiastic reception.

Photos: @nothingelseon, thanks bro.

Sunday, October 16, 2022

Classic Album (and boxset) Review: The Redskins - Neither Washington Nor Moscow (1986/2022 reissue)

The Redskins’ one and only album is a soul-punk classic burning with passion, hope and socialism. It was nothing like any other album of its time, but it’s message resonates in a difficult and troubled time now as much as it did on its initial release.

As depressing as Thatcher’s Britain was in the high unemployment and devastated industrial communities of the 1980s, there was an alternative. In music it began with The Beat’s ‘Stand Down Margaret’ and continued throughout the dirty decade from the likes of the Style Council, The Smiths, Linton Kwesi Johnson and Billy Bragg. The Redskins were at the forefront of the alternative to big hair, spandex trousers and me-first attitudes. They were about solidarity, peace, and anti-racism. This Yorkshire-born three-piece were opinionated, committed and musically brilliant who, in terms of cutting edge polemic and absolute confidence in their beliefs, have rarely if ever been bettered.

 The skinhead three-piece was fronted by Chris Dean, a sometime NME scribe who was inspired by Joe Strummer, who was accompanied by drummer Nick King, and bassist Martin Hewes. Changing their name from No Swastikas to Redskins in 1982, they moved to London and released their debut single in July of that year.

Their emergence was timed perfectly. In 1979 Margaret Thatcher’s Conservative Party won a parliamentary majority and soon began the dismantling of heavy industry, resulting in huge job losses and devastated communities. Most of this occurred in the north, in places like Yorkshire where The Redskins were formed. Fascism and far-right activity was lurking around and the band hated that lot too.

In the early days, The Redskins were more punk than soul. ‘Peasant Army’ contained an inflammatory, angry chorus and was a rousing anthem of optimism. It was as good as, if not better than, the a-side, ‘Lev Bronstein’, who was otherwise known as revolutionary leader Leon Trotsky. Another single was released on CNT in 1983, ‘Lean On Me!’ / ‘Unionize!’ (they loved punctuality), and again the b-side was as good as it’s supposed superior. CNT was an independent label that released early singles for the likes of Sisters of Mercy and The Mekons, and took its name from the confederation of anarcho-syndicalist unions in Spain.

‘Lean On Me’, was a paean to working-class solidarity (“together we’ve a world to win”), and was described by the NME as a “modern soul classic”; Then came further singles ‘Keep On Keepin’ On!’, ‘Bring it Down! (This Insane Thing)’ - a minor chart hit no less, and ‘Kick Over the Statues’. 

‘Keep On Keepin’ On!’ was released at the height of the miner’s strike, with the band at their most prolific, playing benefit gigs around the country and beyond in support of the men and their families who were baton charged, jailed, harassed and ostracised just for defending their jobs. The a-side solemnly noted “Can’t remember such a bitter time/ The boss says jump, the workers fall in line/ They whip us into line with the threat of the dole.”

A raft of singles had been issued over four years but where was the album? That curious anomaly was finally rectified in 1986 when Neither Washington Nor Moscow was issued on Decca. It was something of a greatest hits collection with several of the singles included with just a handful of new tracks.

The album title came from the masthead of the Socialist Worker newspaper, the organ of the SWP which the band were devoted members of. Their support for this small Trotskyist party was unwavering: a speech by Tony Cliff, its de facto leader, was used on one track. Neither Washington Nor Moscow is pretty much the perfect record – 12 tracks, not a single filler, it’s the sound of Detroit meeting Leeds. It rolled The Specials, The Jam, The Impressions, Dexy’s Midnight Runners, and The Supremes into one, and it worked a treat. The anger was channelled magnificently and ‘Kick Over the Statues’ has proved to be prophetic. “Kick over the statues/ And the tyrants die/ Wave bye bye with a hammer/ To their heroes.”

Similarily, the lyrics to ‘It Can Be Done’ could have been written anytime in the past ten years or so: “Hunger of the 30s/ Hunger of the 30s back again/ And the rich still rich/ And the poor still the same as they ever were/ And it seems to me/ We're still not learning from our history.”

Listening to the album in its entirety it seems the answers are so simple … solidarity, unions, strikes, demonstrations, and not backing down. Voting for Neil Kinnock’s Labour Party just wasn’t an option. But, of course, the world isn’t as straightforward as that, and if it was we’d probably be living in a very different society just now.

And as bolshy as it is, it also seems Redskins are just trying too hard. Too hard in telling us the world’s problems which we can all figure out; too hard telling us go on the demo on Saturday, to buy the Socialist Worker newspaper and to persuade all our friends to join us. 

A few months after the album was released the band broke up, not through arguments about the musical direction they should take, but the political stance they should or shouldn’t pursue. Dean’s desire was to write love songs, which was highly ironic given his political outlook. Hewes was less enthusiastic about the idea and believed there was still a battle to fight with Thatcher still in power.

Dean disappeared from the music scene completely and apparently was living a near-hermit existence in Paris and then in York. Releases during the following three decades were limited to a live album, a re-release of the studio album, and a compilation of rarities on a hardcore punk label based in Canada.

 Recently, a four-disk boxset of Neither Washington Nor Moscow was issued by Cherry Red records. At last Redskins’ soul-funk n punk classic was given the royal, expanded treatment. It pretty much contains everything the band did – the album, b-sides, BBC session tracks, extended and alternative versions, live gigs, rarities, demos and bootleg material including some by the first incarnation of the band, No Swastikas. It had the bloody lot and more, and if you wanted to hear the “break mix” of ‘Unionize!’ then you could. The b-sides are all excellent, including ‘You Want It? They’ve Got It!’ which must have been a contender for inclusion on the studio album. All the early singles are here too, and what a joy it is to hear again the likes of ‘Lev Bronstein’ and ‘Unionize!’ …

Their split was timely, perhaps. Given that Neither Washington Nor Moscow contained only a few new tracks and was full of previously-released singles, they may have been struggling for motivation by 1986. They wouldn’t have been spoilt for inspiration had they continued. Thatcher continued her divide and rule tactics, and the Poll Tax, which meant people on the dole paid the same on their council house as a millionaire on his mansion, would have provided a jolt in the arm at the end of the 1980s.

Redskins left on a high, with a wonderful legacy of a back catalogue full of spiky, punk-soul classics that made an impression on, maybe a small amount of people, but people who generally took on their ideals, of using art in politics and of not allowing the bastards you grind you down. Keep on keeping on indeed.